|
Its Not About Gender
Sensational reporting about
Tertiary Entrance scores (Single-sex scores higher, Sun-Herald,
24/6/2001) and segregating the sexes (School’s classes split on gender,
Courier Mail, 25/6/01) illustrates the limited standard of debate on
schooling in Australia. The media tends to focus on the supposedly
newsworthy elements of schooling research such as the issue of single
sex schools, girls doing better or boys failing (How modern teaching
styles help girls outclass their male schoolmates, Sunday Telegraph,
24/6/01; Boys need variety: PM, Shepparton News, 15/6/01; Driven to
excel, Sunday Telegraph, 24/6/01). Unfortunately, the media fail to
raise the strategic issue of relevant schooling.
This current debate ignores the fact that most schools are
co-educational, non-selective and comprehensive and most students are
not university bound. The research finding that the quality of teaching
is the key variable in successful schooling is generally overlooked.
There also is no recognition of the important link between schooling and
a gender-balanced community. The success of young people in work and
tertiary studies should be gauged by how well they are able to work,
live and learn with different people, including the opposite sex. A
letter adds anecdotally (High social cost of better schools, Age,
27/6/01) by revealing difficulties that high score achieving students
from single-sex schools, face in the real world of gender balance. Some
societies need to segregate the sexes in education because of their
cultures (Afghan women plan university, South China Morning Post,
9/6/01), but this is not the case in Australia.
Australia needs to pursue research that informs us about the learning
environment, school culture and the new roles that teachers and
additional leaders must play in the knowledge era. What should follow is
the establishment of a strategic framework for schooling within which
affirmative policies and actions can be implemented to enhance the
considerable talents of all young people.
We should then ask some pertinent questions as illustrated in my letter
(Education research looks in the wrong place, Age, 26/6/01) such as, for
how long will our schools be adequate for girls? As the demand for
knowledge workers and its consequent IT enabled skills increases, for
example, (Girls flock to career forum, Australian, 26/6/01), girls will
start to see that they too are being short-changed by an outdated
schooling system.
Dr David Warner
Principal
Eltham College of Education
PO Box 40
ELTHAM 3095
david.warner@elthamcollege.vic.edu.au |